On September 4, 2023, in Calvert County, Maryland, the investigation into the disappearance of Joe Shymanski began as a missing persons case. Well-known photographer Joe Shymanski, 44, was reported missing when his ex-wife, Heather Snyder, arrived at his home to drop off their children. Heather expressed concern to the deputies when Joe did not appear for the custody exchange. His car was in the driveway, and his personal belongings were inside the house, suggesting he hadn’t left the area.
Sheriff’s deputies conducted a search of the property using various tools, including a drone. Investigation efforts initially centered on questioning Heather Snyder about the couple’s divorce and custody disputes. Neighbors Alison and Colton Pounsberry shared that they had last seen Joe the afternoon prior, helping with some drywall work and then joining them for dinner.
It was unlike Joe to miss this meeting with his children, especially with the visitation being pre-arranged, as described by his older brother, Ted Shymanski.
The morning following Joe’s disappearance, investigators discovered blood on the driveway, changing the trajectory of the investigation. This new evidence prompted authorities to question Heather Snyder further. She disclosed a recent breakup with Brandon Holbrook, a resident near her Pennsylvania home. Upon investigation, police identified Holbrook as a person of interest due to being seen near Joe’s residence on the day he vanished.
Timing played a pivotal role in the case. On September 5, Maryland authorities contacted Sgt. John Chester from Mifflin County, Pennsylvania, regarding their murder investigation connected to Brandon Holbrook. Known to local authorities for previous indecent exposure convictions, Holbrook’s investigation revealed his nervous demeanor and contradictions about his whereabouts on the day of the disappearance.
The morning of September 6, led by Sgt. John Chester, authorities arrested Holbrook upon discovering gloves, plastic sheeting, human blood, and existence of clean-up items. In the subsequent search, authorities discovered human remains in a nearby clearing, including a jawbone with intact teeth, indicating a dismembered body left for burning.
Simultaneously, those close to Joe shared fond memories of his creativity and mentorship, recalling happier times before his disappearance. Heather Snyder and others provided varying perspectives on their strained relationship. She cited instances of emotional and, allegedly, physical abuse during their marriage.
Within weeks, forensic experts confirmed the remains found in the clearing were of Joe Shymanski, who died from a gunshot wound to the head. Despite evidence suggesting Holbrook’s involvement, Heather Snyder, who claimed her innocence, faced speculation about her role. The defense alleged that her naming in Joe’s life insurance policy as a potential beneficiary was a motive.
During the trial that began on March 31, 2025, prosecutors pressed for a conviction on premeditated murder, emphasizing Holbrook’s involvement. They introduced evidence of Holbrook’s presence proximate to Joe’s home and the subsequent concealment efforts.
The defense team redirected attention to Heather Snyder as a potential suspect, questioning her actions before and after Joe’s disappearance. Video evidence showed Snyder purchasing pizza in Pennsylvania, offering her an alibi. A crucial point of contention involved a gun allegedly given to Snyder by Holbrook before the murder, not previously searched by authorities.
Despite claims of innocence, Heather Snyder invoked her Fifth Amendment rights, opting not to testify. Holbrook was absent from the witness stand, leaving the jury to deliberate on the presented evidence.
The rapid jury decision found Brandon Holbrook guilty of first-degree premeditated murder. Joe’s family expressed satisfaction with the verdict, though they continue to suspect joint involvement, citing frustrations with investigative directions. Despite the conviction, Heather Snyder has not been charged nor identified as an official suspect.
Contributing factors in this intricate case include ongoing legal appeals and attempts for full resolution. A scholarship in Joe Shymanski’s name supports aspiring photography students, ensuring his creative legacy lives on. The case remains open within the legal system, despite a concluded trial.