The Anoka-Hennepin school board is nearing a decision on whether to continue or revamp social and emotional learning (SEL) lessons, following extensive debates. This decision comes amidst broader cultural disputes over educational content in schools.
Curriculum Controversy
Board Member Matt Audette opposes external SEL programs. He advocates for a system developed within the district to maintain oversight. Conversely, Board Co-chair Kacy Deschene supports the existing curriculum, noting its positive impact on academic performance and its broad approval among parents and teachers. The board remains divided, delaying a final decision.
Understanding SEL
SEL involves teaching students skills like emotional management, goal setting, and relationship building. This approach connects to older character education models, emphasizing traits like honesty and responsibility. Inspired by past events like the Columbine shooting and backed by Minnesota legislation, SEL aims to improve student safety and reduce bullying. The initiative gained momentum following the COVID-19 pandemic due to rising mental health concerns.
Implementation in Anoka-Hennepin
The district employs the Leader in Me and CharacterStrong programs across various schools. These curricula focus on character development through short, regular lessons integrated into the school day. Activities encourage discussions on concepts like gratitude and foster social skills. Tom Shaw, the district’s director of student services, notes the simplicity of these sessions, focusing on strengthening student relationships.
Rising Debate
SEL once shared bipartisan support but became politically charged alongside other education debates post-2020. As discussions around critical race theory and equity policies intensified, some conservative groups began questioning SEL. Concerns rose about SEL teaching liberal ideologies under the guise of social justice.
Parental Perspectives
While most parents agree with the aims of SEL, the term itself may cause unease, especially among Republicans. A 2021 national survey highlighted parental concerns about instruction time. However, an Anoka-Hennepin survey indicated broad parental and teacher support for SEL, although time constraints were a common issue.
Research Findings
Research underscores SEL’s academic benefits. A 2011 analysis linked SEL programs to an 11-point increase in academic achievement. In 2023-2024, over 60% of U.S. public schools had formal SEL curricula, with over a quarter reporting significant positive outcomes.
Next Steps
The future of SEL in Anoka-Hennepin hangs in balance as the school board prepares to make a final decision. Superintendent Cory McIntyre emphasizes the importance of SEL in boosting student achievement, urging a resolution to the ongoing debate.

Clarification on Policy for LGBTQ+ Students in New York School District
Colleges Struggle With Hazing and Drug Issues
Stalemate Over Ethnic Studies Leaves Teachers Seeking Direction
Students Serve Thanksgiving Dinner and Learn Agriculture at Chicago High School for Agricultural Sciences
Current Events Recap
Scrutiny Over AI Gun Detection in Schools: Lawsuits and Challenges