Retired police sergeant Betsy Brantner Smith, with nearly 30 years of law enforcement experience, expressed concerns about visiting New York City. Her caution arises from Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s decision to dismantle a specialized NYPD unit, the Strategic Response Group (SRG), which handled counterterrorism and crowd control.
Mamdani, fulfilling a campaign promise, intends to separate counterterrorism from protest policing. Critics worry that disbanding the SRG could weaken emergency response capabilities. Smith noted that the unit’s officers had the expertise to manage complex situations, including active shooter scenarios.
“These officers train together, understand each other’s roles, and can respond swiftly and safely,” Smith emphasized.
The news comes as the city prepares for large events, like the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade. Smith fears that dismantling the unit might lead to operational gaps.
Assistant Commissioner Brad Weeks assured that security for the parade would remain unaffected. The restructuring will involve transferring counterterrorism officers to the NYPD’s Counterterrorism Bureau, with new divisions ready by 2027.
Mayor Mamdani reiterated that protest and counterterrorism roles are distinct. His overhaul will also limit certain police tactics, like banning long guns and tear gas, and restrict the use of pepper spray for crowd control.
The changes will unfold over the coming months, with new divisions focusing on community dialogue and de-escalation. Mamdani rejected claims that civilians would replace police in dealing with violent protests.
NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch defended the restructuring, affirming that the department will retain necessary resources to address threats. Some activist groups praised the decision, viewing it as a victory for protest rights.
The National Police Association launched a petition urging Mamdani to reinstate the SRG. Nearly 2,000 people signed within two days, citing its importance for public safety.
Smith urged city officials to maintain the NYPD’s capability to function effectively. “We urge the mayor of New York City to continue to allow the NYPD to do everything in its power to keep the city safe,” she stated.

Flavio Bolsonaro Claims Political Persecution Led to U.S. Asylum
Key Developments in U.S. Politics and International Affairs
Ex-Oath Keepers Leader Turns Against Trump
Progressive Democrats Seek to Push Agenda in House
Controversy Surrounds Governor Newsom’s Death Sentence Commutation Plan
Jewish Activist Criticizes Event Cancellation at CUNY School