Menu

Jennifer Sey Challenges Colorado Law in Business Dispute

5 days ago 0

Jennifer Sey, founder of XX-XY Athletics, is expressing strong distrust towards the state of Colorado. Her company, focused on safeguarding women’s sports, is embroiled in a legal battle over a law she argues could threaten her business’s foundational principles.

Attorney Hal Frampton, representing XX-XY Athletics, disclosed to OutKick that violations of Colorado’s anti-discrimination law could result in penalties as high as $3,500 per incident. Certain advertising violations might be classified as a Class 2 misdemeanor, resulting in up to 120 days of imprisonment.

Despite these concerns, Colorado has not yet taken any action against the company since the law’s passage in 2025. The state argues that legal protection should not be granted during ongoing litigation.

Sey is not persuaded. Previously a Levi Strauss & Co. senior executive, she launched XX-XY Athletics in 2020 after disputes over COVID lockdowns.

The central issue revolves around the Kelly Loving Act (HB 25-1312), a 2025 legislation broadening anti-discrimination protection to encompass chosen names and terms of address. Sey and her attorneys believe this might force businesses to use pronouns contrary to their views.

After court arguments on Monday, Sey’s attorneys seek to secure protection before any complaints are filed. Frampton, from the Alliance Defending Freedom, emphasized that Americans shouldn’t need to be prosecuted to challenge unconstitutional laws.

XX-XY Athletics holds firm views on biological sex. Its campaigns regularly oppose the involvement of biological males in female sports. Sey recently spearheaded a campaign for Proposition 134, which passed with about 52% voter support. This measure, effective January 1, mandates sports teams in K-12 and collegiate levels be designated by biological sex.

Sey acknowledged the campaign’s difficulty, with minimal funding compared to the $4.5 million spent by opponents. She believes the anti-discrimination law jeopardizes open discourse on these issues.

The lawsuit covers company practices of identifying transgender athletes by biological sex. An example cited was a post about a male athlete in a girls’ track event, stating, “When boys run girls’ track, they win, and girls lose.” Sey’s legal representatives argue such expressions could potentially lead to discrimination allegations under Colorado’s broadened gender expression definition.

Sey contends the repercussions extend beyond possible fines. She argues against being compelled to use language at odds with her company’s stance, which could dilute their position on policy challenges.

Although a federal judge refused their preliminary injunction request in March, determining no credible threat of law enforcement, Colorado insists the concerns are overstated. State attorney Janna Fischer indicated the changes in 2025 did not alter substantive rights under the Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act.

Sey perceives the issue as broader, affecting all ventures and individuals, suggesting it instills fear about truthfully speaking up.

The legal challenge is set against Colorado’s historical free speech disputes. Previous Supreme Court rulings have favored business owners’ free speech rights, as in the 2018 Masterpiece Cakeshop case.

Commenting on the ongoing legal climate, Frampton noted Colorado’s historical clashes with the Supreme Court on such themes, recounting three notable cases to the Rocky Mountain Voice.

Governor-elect Phil Weiser hinted at possible modifications to Proposition 134, stating it’s a statutory measure subject to legislative amendments. Sey, involved for two years in its passage, seems unwavering in ensuring it reflects the electorate’s choice.

Leave a Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *