Menu

Caitlyn Jenner Rebukes Seattle Times Article on Transgender Athletes in Sports

5 days ago 0

Caitlyn Jenner criticized a Seattle Times article that claimed there is no serious scientific evidence suggesting transgender athletes have a competitive advantage over biological women. During an appearance on ‘America Reports,’ the Olympic gold medalist and Fox News contributor engaged with co-anchor John Roberts, advocating for women’s sports. Jenner cited physical differences and personal experiences from her Olympic career to challenge the newspaper’s assertion.

The Seattle Times quickly published a story responding to independent journalist Nick Shirley, who had retracted his accusation against Lam’s Seafood Asian Market, alleging EBT fraud. The market, a mainstay in Seattle’s International District, asserted it was wrongly accused. Holding journalists accountable for false claims aligns with the mission of newspapers, yet questions arise when the newspaper itself makes disputed claims.

The Times’ article examined the public’s support for Initiative 638 in Washington, which seeks to prohibit biological males from competing in girls’ K-12 sports. Despite fair representation of diverse views in the article, a controversial paragraph questioned the existence of scientific evidence that supports claims of athletic advantage by transgender athletes.

Numerous critics have disputed the Times’ claims. Studies cited include a 2020 study of U.S. Air Force personnel showing that transgender women remained 12% faster in a 1.5-mile run after two years of hormone therapy. Further research demonstrates that significant advantages in strength, power, size, and aerobic capacity can persist even after testosterone suppression. A review highlighted that transgender women typically retain 95% of their muscle mass following a year of hormone therapy.

Experienced journalists like Karen Crouse pointed to a 2021 review showing that even after three years of hormone treatment, strength, lean mass, and muscle size still exceeded levels observed in female athletes. The 2023 American College of Sports Medicine also documented performance advantages gained during male puberty.

Despite such evidence, the Seattle Times has not retracted or clarified their assertion. Reaction to criticism has been varied, but responses from the newspaper have been scant. Critics, including investigative journalist Benjamin Ryan, have noted the lack of response to their inquiries.

Concerns are growing about the newspaper’s credibility if it publishes claims contrary to peer-reviewed science without addressing critiques. Matt Calkins, a columnist for Outkick with extensive experience in sports journalism, raised this issue, advocating for transparency and accountability. He reflects on his own career, understanding the importance of correcting mistakes in journalism.

Leave a Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *