In 1848, Horace Mann described public schools as “the great equalizer of the conditions of men.” Over 175 years later, the debate on this assertion continues. Some research highlights the impact of family background on a child’s academic success more than schools. Other studies indicate schools help bridge the achievement gaps that could otherwise widen.
A notable study from the 1980s on Baltimore children revealed that low-income and wealthier children learned at similar rates during the school year. However, disparities widened over summer breaks, with some children enjoying educational activities like reading with parents and attending camps, while others lacked such opportunities. The extent of summer learning loss is still debated, but the point is clear: sizeable gaps in reading and math skills exist by kindergarten, primarily due to factors outside K-12 schooling. These gaps remain nearly constant throughout the school years.
As an education policy scholar, I examine the various factors influencing student learning, including teacher quality. Typically, assessments focus on what students learn in school. Recently, my colleagues and I evaluated what students receive both in and outside of school, including funding, educational support services, and time devoted by schools, government programs, and families.
The Early Start of Investment Gaps
In a 2026 study, we utilized ten nationally representative government surveys to assess 77 “investment” types involved in child-rearing and education. These range from teachers and tutoring to housing and food. We assigned a dollar value to each factor, valuing parental time based on the average U.S. hourly wage, to compare resources among children from different backgrounds.
Our analysis shows that an average U.S. child receives approximately $502,000 in investments from birth to age 18. Notably, gaps in resource allocation start early. By age five, children from the poorest quartile receive roughly $44,000 less than those from the wealthiest quartile — a 24% gap largely due to housing and childcare costs.
As children enter elementary school, investment gaps narrow significantly. The divide between wealthiest and poorest children reduces from 24% to 12%. The benefit is even more pronounced for Black children, whose investment gap compared to white children shrinks from 20% to 7% upon reaching kindergarten.
The Role of Schools in Equalizing Investments
Research links increased school spending to better student achievements and long-term outcomes, particularly for low-income families. Yet, achievement gaps remain steady through school years. This persistence can partly be explained by how money influences outcomes.
Our findings show that once schooling begins, children from low-income families receive significantly more resources in tutoring and special education compared to their wealthier counterparts. For instance, low-income families access 72% more tutoring and 68% more special education services. Black children also receive more tutoring than white children. These resources focus on helping students catch up.
Tutoring is a key strategy employed by schools to address academic disparities. Following the pandemic, reliance on tutoring increased, supported by federal funds. Congress allocated nearly $190 billion for educational recovery. By 2022-23, over a third of public schools offered frequent, small-group tutoring sessions. However, tutoring was already common among low-income Black and Latino students. As of recent data, 15% of children were tutored nationwide, and public schools primarily delivered this support to minority students.
Pandemic conditions exacerbated achievement gaps. Despite federal relief, high-poverty districts struggled to close these gaps. Schools increased reliance on existing support mechanisms, including tutoring.
Resources That Propel Ahead
Beyond catch-up interventions, wealthier children enjoy additional advantages in and out of school. Evidence suggests low-income and minority students are often paired with less experienced teachers compared to wealthier white students. Outside of school, wealthier families invest more heavily in enrichment activities, such as music lessons and sports — significant boosters for children’s development.
By 2024, the top 10% of families spent over 13 times more per child on childcare, education, and extracurricular activities than the lowest 25% — an increase from three times as much spent in the early 1980s.
Redefining Equal Opportunity
While public education narrows the investment gap, this alone does not equate to equal opportunity. Much of schools’ extra spending compensates for initial multi-faceted disadvantages. In contrast, wealthier children continue receiving advanced resources and experienced instructors that facilitate further advancement.
To truly equalize opportunities and not just maintain the status quo, children from marginalized backgrounds must receive comparable advancement resources. Considering that the most substantial disparities begin before kindergarten — notably in areas like housing and childcare — solutions need to go beyond schools.
David Blazar, Malen Professor for Urban Education Policy, University of Maryland
This article has been republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license.
Jewish Activist Criticizes Event Cancellation at CUNY School
Debate on School Choice in Texas Elections
Clarification on Policy for LGBTQ+ Students in New York School District
Colleges Struggle With Hazing and Drug Issues
Stalemate Over Ethnic Studies Leaves Teachers Seeking Direction
Anoka-Hennepin School Board Debates Future of Social and Emotional Learning