A Revitalized ‘Dirty Dancing: The Musical’ Shines on Stage

Lonny Price, the director, has crafted an impressive version of “Dirty Dancing: The Musical” that offers a fresh experience on stage. Historically, this title, based on the popular 1987 film starring Jennifer Grey and Patrick Swayze, lacked theatrical refinement and quality. After debuting in Australia and the U.K., a prior U.S. rendition did not impress during its run around 17 years ago.

That earlier staging was marred by basic video effects, such as flickering fireplaces, and performances that felt cliché, leaving an impression of cashing in on the movie’s nostalgia. The new touring production, starting at Chicago’s Nederlander Theatre, is a noteworthy transformation.

Audience appeal remains strong, and this version could thrive with a limited Broadway stint akin to “Mamma Mia!” It features improved choreography by Darrell Grand Moultrie, renowned for his work on Beyoncé’s world tour. Moultrie blends period authenticity with social dancing elements reminiscent of the film.

Unique to this staging, the production incorporates more from the American songbook, including classics like “Fly Me to the Moon.” Moultrie skillfully captures the essence of the Catskills setting, where patrons and creative staff alike demonstrate their dancing prowess, combined with an underlayer of sexual tension.

Price’s strategic casting enhances the experience. The new Equity company showcases dancers with acting depth. Essential parts like Baby and Johnny prioritize dance skills over singing, with pivotal music numbers performed by secondary characters.

The principal performers include Blake Zelesnikar as Johnny, known for “An American in Paris,” Olivia Cece from Broadway’s “Moulin Rouge” as Penny, and newcomer Annalese Starzec as Baby. Starzec, who bears a striking resemblance to Jennifer Grey, captures the humor and charm necessary for the role.

The script, penned by Eleanor Bergstein, remains faithful to the original movie. While updates or enhancements could enrich the theatrical aspects, the current production benefits from Brett J. Banakis’s elegant and cliché-resistant set design, showcasing the Catskills’ allure.

Performance highlights include Bryan Fenkart, who pays homage to Jerry Orbach’s original portrayal of Jake Houseman. Fenkart delivers a moving performance that acknowledges his predecessor’s legacy.

With standout vocal contributions from Ashley LaLonde and Erick Pinnick, the show provides a thoroughly enjoyable evening of theater. While “Dirty Dancing” remains a theatrical expression of the beloved film, its story and appeal persist for devoted fans.

Performances run through September 20 at the Nederlander Theatre in Chicago. Tickets range from $40 to $155, available at 312-977-1700 or online at broadwayinchicago.com.