Rich Eisen Steps Down from NFL Play-by-Play Role

Rich Eisen has confirmed that he will no longer serve as a play-by-play commentator for NFL games following ESPN’s acquisition of NFL Network. He shared this decision in a conversation with Sports Illustrated, indicating that his time calling games has concluded.

Eisen began commentating NFL games on NFL Network around 2018, regularly participating in the network’s international broadcasts alongside color analyst Kurt Warner. Sources have indicated that ESPN made the call to remove Eisen from these game broadcasts. Dave Pasch is expected to step in to replace him. Pasch, previously with the Arizona Cardinals, is considered an accomplished and skilled play-by-play commentator, bringing a fresh approach to NFL Network-exclusive games.

Though Eisen maintained his role for multiple seasons, his commentary often faced criticism. He was noted for using clichés, talking over replays, and frequently referring to midfield as “the shield.” His tendency to speak in a passive voice was also highlighted.

In his conversation with Sports Illustrated, Eisen recognized these challenges. He attributed them to habits formed as a studio host. “I enjoyed doing it, but it’s very different from my usual role,” he mentioned. He explained the contrast between the live, reactive nature of game commentary and his instinctual response to fill dead air from his studio experiences.

While some, like NBC’s Mike Tirico, have successfully juggled both studio and play-by-play roles, Eisen’s strengths remain more aligned with studio hosting. Despite stepping away from game broadcasts, his position at ESPN remains secure. He continues to host his daily radio show on ESPN Radio and Disney+ and has participated in various special editions of SportsCenter.

Around the industry, Eisen’s contributions are viewed with mixed opinions. Many recognize him as a talented studio anchor, yet he also draws criticism for frequently referencing his history from the 1990s. Additionally, his political engagements on his radio show have set him apart from ESPN’s typical positioning.

Ultimately, Eisen still holds significant value in sports commentary, though not in the role of a play-by-play commentator. ESPN identified his strengths and reassigned him accordingly before the commencement of the NFL season.