New York Magazine’s Men’s Style Issue Sparks Debate

New York Magazine has launched its inaugural men’s style issue, prominently featuring transgender actor Elliot Page, a biological female. This edition explores men’s fashion history, recalling past coverage such as a 1971 report speculating on men wearing high heels and a 1996 profile on male supermodels. The magazine’s past issues occasionally included a mini men’s magazine section.

The magazine states that, amidst modern trends like teenage enthusiasm for designer brands and costly vintage jeans, the current moment is apt for a men’s style special. The issue highlights influential figures in the fashion business, emerging trends, and enduring semi-supermodels. It avoids proclaiming a new men’s clothing revolution, though hints at changing styles.

Elliot Page discussed experiencing masculinity by interacting with male fans.

The issue also has multiple covers, including one featuring Page, with articles like “The Boys in the Baths,” which details stylish men at the Russian & Turkish Baths in New York’s East Village. Page shared insights on visiting a bathhouse, mentioning comfort in body acceptance and a penchant for singing shower songs, such as “Do You Believe in Life After Love?”

Critics, like political commentator Link Lauren, condemned the magazine for highlighting Page in a masculine context, aligning with wider criticism that media suppresses masculinity, often labeling it toxic. Lauren accused the magazine of exploiting Page for controversy rather than a genuine interest in style.

Tim Graham of NewsBusters criticized the feature, questioning the inclusion of Page, drawing comparisons to past editorial choices like featuring a transgender woman in Glamour’s ‘Women of the Year.’ Graham suggested the move entices progressive praise while ignoring traditional distinctions.

New York Magazine’s choice spurred debate on media portrayals, stirring reactions and contemplation on gender representation.