Amanda Seyfried Faces Backlash after New Elizabeth Holmes Documentary

Amanda Seyfried’s appearance in the latest Elizabeth Holmes documentary stirred criticism online. Viewers expressed surprise when she appeared alongside Nathan Fielder in “You Can See Everything.” This documentary follows Holmes in the 34 days before her prison sentence, which started on May 30, 2023.

Seyfried revisited her connection to Holmes, whom she portrayed in Hulu’s “The Dropout.” The new documentary, released on October 16, explored Seyfried’s evolving views on Holmes, including her reactions to Holmes’ personal life and relationship with Billy Evans. Seyfried helped Fielder recreate conversations he had with Holmes after she entered prison.

The documentary is worth watching for its revelations on Holmes’ final days before imprisonment.

Throughout the film, Seyfried grappled with mixed feelings toward Holmes. The convicted fraudster had challenged Seyfried’s portrayal of her in the Hulu series. Seyfried’s appearance sparked accusations of hypocrisy among viewers.

One social media user commented on Seyfried’s defense of Holmes as a victim until Holmes critiqued her portrayal of the scandal, calling Seyfried’s reaction “truly gross.” Another user accused Seyfried of backtracking amid scrutiny of her role in the scandal’s TV adaptation.

Defending Seyfried: Some viewers defended Seyfried, arguing her shift in opinion was part of the documentary’s message. One user said, “Amanda’s change in opinion reflects a broader understanding,” adding that Seyfried’s evolution was an essential narrative element.

Holmes, convicted in January 2022 on four fraud charges, was sentenced to over 11 years in federal prison. “You Can See Everything” examines her efforts to reclaim her public image, preparing her for a world post-scandal and exploring how she and the public view her.