Theismann on Rodgers’ Return to Steelers with McCarthy

The Pittsburgh Steelers secured Aaron Rodgers for another season. According to Super Bowl champion Joe Theismann, head coach Mike McCarthy is the primary reason for Rodgers’ decision to return.

Theismann, 76, explained that Rodgers might not have come back if faced with learning a new system and playbook. “I think Aaron coming back was a no-brainer for me because Mike McCarthy’s there,” Theismann stated in an interview with Fox News Digital.

Aaron Rodgers of the Pittsburgh Steelers stands during the national anthem before an NFL game against the Baltimore Ravens at Acrisure Stadium in Pittsburgh, Pa., on Jan. 4, 2026.

Theismann added, “If there was a different coordinator, I don’t think Aaron would have come back. With Mike there, I felt 90-10 he would return.” McCarthy and Rodgers share a strong bond from their 13 seasons with the Green Bay Packers. The familiarity in their system should ease Rodgers’ transition in Pittsburgh.

Theismann believes Rodgers won’t have to spend much time in OTAs understanding terminology and reads. “He could coach anybody on the system they’re likely to run,” Theismann said, suggesting Rodgers’ comfort with not having to learn a new playbook.

Last season, Rodgers demonstrated effectiveness by completing 65.7% of his passes for 3,322 yards, with 24 touchdowns and seven interceptions across 16 games. Despite his advancing age of 42, Rodgers’ arm strength remains undeniable. However, his mobility has declined, highlighting the importance of strong offensive line play.

Rodgers can still throw well, but at 42 his mobility isn’t what it once was,” Theismann remarked.

“He’s going to get the ball out quickly,” Theismann advised. “But they need to strengthen the offensive line to protect him.” The Steelers must allow Rodgers time to hold the ball and make downfield plays.

Despite a change in head coach after nearly two decades, Theismann expects the Steelers’ football identity to remain intact. “Pittsburgh is still going to be Pittsburgh. Their mentality isn’t going to change. They’re a tough football team in a tough division, and Aaron has shown his toughness,” Theismann affirmed.

Former NFL player Joe Theismann converses with sportscaster Chris Collinsworth before a game at Northwest Stadium in Landover, Md.,

Having spent 12 seasons in the NFL with the Washington Redskins, Theismann was a league MVP in 1983 and twice a Pro Bowler. He led the Redskins to a 27-17 victory over the Miami Dolphins in Super Bowl XVII. Over his career, Theismann completed 56.7% of his passes for 25,206 yards, 160 touchdowns, and 138 interceptions.

Theismann will participate in the American Century Championship at Edgewood Golf Course in Lake Tahoe from July 10-12. The event will air on NBC and Peacock.