The Indianapolis Colts showed limited activity at the NFL trade deadline, echoing their underwhelming performance this season. Despite receiving various offers for star running back Jonathan Taylor, they chose to retain him. Offers included multiple draft picks, some of them high, but the Colts sought a significant deal they ultimately did not receive.
Reports indicate that the New York Giants presented an offer involving second- and fifth-round selections in exchange for Taylor. This proposal echoed a deal the San Francisco 49ers made for Christian McCaffrey, but Indianapolis aspired for a No. 1 pick. When that did not materialize, the team decided against trading Taylor, informing him of their decision by early Tuesday afternoon. This retained him on a team that struggles with a record of 2-7.
The Colts also explored trading their starting quarterback, Daniel Jones. Conversations with the Minnesota Vikings took place, yet like Taylor, Jones remained untraded. These decisions were part of broader trade considerations by the Colts, looking at future draft capitals.
In contrast, the team did execute trades for wide receivers Josh Downs and Keenan Allen. Downs, who requested a trade, and the 34-year-old Allen, both on expiring contracts, moved to new teams. The Colts received a fourth- and fifth-round pick from the Kansas City Chiefs for Downs and a 2027 sixth-rounder from the San Francisco 49ers for Allen.
The team’s approach to trades raises questions. The refusal to offload Taylor puzzled many, especially after his apparent farewell following a recent defeat to the Dallas Cowboys. Additionally, the Colts declined an upgraded offer for defensive tackle Grover Stewart. Originally, a fifth-round pick was on the table, later increased to a fourth-round and a late-round selection. As they waited for a better offer, the existing ones were revoked.
This strategy is part of a complex messaging approach from the Colts front office. Reports suggest that the team aims to retain key players as enticing options for potential new management, should coach Shane Steichen face dismissal. This reasoning seems questionable since upcoming management may prefer an increased number of draft picks over existing players.
Frustration surrounds the Colts’ current season and trade decisions. The team’s future strategies remain unclear, adding to the uncertainty surrounding their performance and management decisions.
Follow Armando Salguero on X for more insider coverage on the Colts and NFL. Salguero serves as a Senior NFL Writer at OutKick.

Shohei Ohtani’s New Balance Deal Amid MLB Lockout Concerns
Buzelis and Giddey Face Challenges in Bulls’ Rebuild
Rivalry Intensifies Ahead of Army-Navy Game
Deaf Texas Student-Athlete Secures Multiple College Offers
Viral College Football Game Couple Captures Social Media Attention
Jaylen Harrell Hospitalized After Serious Car Accident