Democrats have gained a slight lead over Republicans in which party Americans trust most to handle the economy. This is the first time since December 2017 that Democrats have led in polling by NBC News. The shift comes as November midterms approach, with economic concerns poised to influence close congressional races. Candidates from both parties need to appeal to voters unsatisfied with current economic conditions.
The Dissolution of Republican Economic Advantage
Republicans have traditionally held an advantage in handling economic matters. Three years ago, their lead was 21 points according to NBC News polling. This advantage has faded, as most voters now feel Trump’s policies have negatively impacted the economy. Although Democrats’ one-point lead falls within the poll’s margin of error, the overall trend is noteworthy.
Key Statistics:
- 39% of voters trust Democrats over Republicans (38%) to manage the economy.
- 55% believe Trump’s policies hurt the economy, while 26% think they helped.
- Democrats lead by 7 points in controlling inflation, 38% to 31%.
- Trump has an approval rating of 41%, with 56% disapproving.
- Democrats lead the congressional ballot by five points, 50% to 45%.
Recent Polling Developments
According to the latest NBC News survey, the historic Republican advantage in economic trust has essentially vanished. The poll surveyed 1,000 registered voters from September 11 to 15 using both phone interviews and an online method. Conducted by Public Opinion Strategies, this survey was completed with the Democratic firm Hart Research Associates.
Its margin of error was 3.1 percentage points. While lacking statistical decisiveness, the gradual movement is significant. Just three years ago, Republican favor was far stronger at 49-28%.
Regarding inflation, a significant issue for Americans, Democrats hold a seven-point advantage over Republicans.
Voter Responses:
- 55% said Trump’s policies harmed the economy. The negative view increased from 48% in March.
- In 2018, prior to midterms, 26% believed Trump’s policies hurt the economy.
Trump’s Recent Economic Proposal Faces Resistance
Trump faced backlash for his proposal at the Republican convention to provide each adult with $5,000 if the GOP maintained congressional control. In the NBC News poll, 21% were more likely to support the idea, while 46% were less likely.
A Marquette Law School Poll conducted from September 2 to 9 noted inflation and living costs as top issues for 37% of adults, which beats the broader economy at 16%. The survey included 1,023 adults and had a 3.3 percentage point margin of error.
Prediction Markets and Electoral Insights
Kalshi reported a 61% chance of Democrats sweeping Congress as of September 22. There was a 30% chance for a Democratic House and Republican Senate, an 8.7% chance for a Republican sweep, and 0.9% for a Democratic Senate with a Republican House.
These prediction markets gauge contract prices linked to future outcomes, rapidly changing with polls and campaign events. They reflect traders’ expectations rather than definitive forecasts.
Implications for Democrats
The NBC News poll shows a 50% to 45% lead for Democrats on a generic ballot, which queries voter preference without mentioning specific candidates. The five-point gap is narrower than the 12-point lead held at this time in 2018, which saw Democrats take control of the House.
The survey suggests Democrats’ image remains more negative than the Republicans’ despite opposition to Trump motivating voters. Held views of Republicans tend to be more favorable than Democrats.
Twenty-nine percent view Democrats positively, while 50% negatively. Republicans score 36% positive and 49% negative.
Jeff Horwitt of Hart Research Associates noted the historic level of voter opposition to Trump, indicating more dissatisfaction with him and the Republican Party, rather than an endorsement of Democrats.
According to Bill McInturff of Public Opinion Strategies, political geography remains crucial; elections hinge on these geographical factors despite national polling trends.
Newsweek’s article was created with the assistance of Martyn, an AI. Contact editors Matthew Cannon and James Debens for more information.

Political Shifts and Leadership Challenges in U.S. Politics
UN General Assembly and Middle East Diplomacy Amid Rising Tensions
U.S. Secures New Greenland Security Agreement
Criticism of NYC’s Office of Mass Engagement
Senator Calls for Investigation into Donald Trump Jr’s Affairs
Diesel Prices Hit Record Highs Amid Global Tensions