Revamping the NFL Kicking Game

In recent years, NFL kickers have significantly improved, consistently achieving longer, higher, and straighter kicks. Despite their prowess, these plays have become predictable and somewhat dull, often overlooked by fans. The NFL’s previous attempts to invigorate the kicking game, such as altering extra points and kickoff rules, have been largely ineffective. Below are four proposed changes to enhance excitement and strategy in the game.

1. Adding a Crossbar to Field Goal Posts

Kansas City Chiefs place kicker Harrison Butker celebrates after scoring against the Los Angeles Rams during the first half of an NFL preseason football game, Saturday, Aug. 15, 2026, in Kansas City, Mo.

Transforming the posts into a rectangle heightens the challenge for kickers, requiring strategic precision to place the ball within the uprights without excessively elevating it. This configuration ensures each kick demands skillful aim rather than raw distance, making routine 38-yard kicks more interesting. With kickers capable of achieving 70-80-yard field goals in practice, it’s time to introduce complexity into their task.

2. Eliminating the Opening Coin Toss and Starting Kickoff

Miami Dolphins wide receiver Tyreek Hill is tackled by New York Jets running back Isaiah Davis during a punt return during the first half at MetLife Stadium on Jan. 5, 2025.

Initiating games with a footrace between two players to retrieve the game ball at the 50-yard line introduces a new level of excitement. This competition determines which team starts at their own 20-yard line, creating dynamic starts and minimizing predictable kickoff scenarios.

3. Redefining the Kickoff after Scoring

Instead of a traditional kickoff, the scoring team begins at their own 35-yard line with a single play to advance 20 yards and keep possession. If unsuccessful, control shifts to the defense. This modification resembles a punt play, known for its unpredictability and offering strategic depth without the standard safety concerns of kickoff plays.

4. Reforming Sudden Death Overtime

Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen questions a call during the first half of the AFC championship NFL football game against the Kansas City Chiefs, Sunday, Jan. 24, 2021, in Kansas City, Mo.

Avoiding the advantages often granted by sudden death overtime, adopting similar regulations seen in college football and high schools ensures fairness. Both teams receive possession opportunities, eliminating the coin toss. The home team initially decides on actions, alternating if tied, until a winner emerges. This system promotes extended tactical play and enhances competitive balance.

These amendments aim to promote tactical engagement and invigorate the viewing experience. Implementing them in next year’s preseason games can test their effectiveness. Additionally, adopting larger, safer helmets and limiting elaborate halftime shows can help focus on the sport’s essence.

Jason Chaffetz, a former college placekicker and current Fox News Contributor, offers these suggestions to move football toward a more captivating future.