Idaho Bathroom Ban Blocked by Federal Judge

A federal judge has halted a new Idaho law that criminalizes using certain restrooms unless they match a person’s sex at birth. This temporary injunction is a relief for transgender individuals in Idaho, who faced severe penalties under the statute. The law, considered notably stringent in the U.S., was set to commence on July 1.

The case, initiated by six transgender Idaho residents, asserts that the law breaches constitutional protections, including equal protection rights and privacy concerns. However, Judge Amanda K. Brailsford of the U.S. District Court highlighted that an immediate decision was possible due to the likelihood of success on a different claim: the law’s vagueness.

Judge Brailsford stated that the statute may be unconstitutional as it requires subjective assessments by officers, such as determining an individual’s biological sex. The law imposes criminal charges, potentially a felony for repeat offenses, yet leaves enforcement discretion to officers without clear guidance.

With her recent appointment by former President Joseph R. Biden Jr., Judge Brailsford’s decision halts part of the law during ongoing legal proceedings. The ruling means transgender individuals can use single-stall restrooms aligning with their gender identity, or multi-user restrooms if single stalls are occupied or unavailable on the same floor. The challenge does not extend to parts of the law regarding locker rooms and showers.