The Michigan Senate race has become a focal point of controversy as Democratic nominee Abdul El-Sayed faces backlash for remarks involving Vice President JD Vance’s family.
A decade ago, JD Vance expressed regret that his grandparents never met his wife, Usha. In his memoir “Hillbilly Elegy,” Vance reflected on his fondness for his wife and lamented that his Mamaw and Papaw could not meet her. This sentiment was revisited in recent criticism of El-Sayed.
El-Sayed, who is in a heated race against Republican Mike Rogers for Michigan’s open Senate seat, commented on Vance’s family during a rally. After Vance criticized El-Sayed’s past remarks on Sharia law, El-Sayed questioned whether Vance would “take Usha with him back in time to meet Papaw.” Critics interpreted this as insinuating that Vance’s grandfather might not have accepted Usha due to her Indian heritage.
“So do we think JD is taking Usha with him back in time to meet Papaw, or no,” El-Sayed remarked, sparking a wave of criticism.
Texas Rep. Brandon Gill questioned El-Sayed’s assumptions about midwestern grandparents. Meghan McCain responded strongly, defending Usha Vance as a respected figure. Commentator Ryan Girdusky and journalist Emily Schrader also voiced their disapproval.
JD Vance’s memoir, published in 2016, offers insight into his upbringing in Middletown, Ohio, and his family’s roots in Kentucky. His grandparents played significant roles in his life story, making recent discussions about them and his wife particularly sensitive.
Representatives for El-Sayed and the Vance family have not yet commented on the situation.
As the election approaches, El-Sayed’s comments have intensified scrutiny of his campaign and the broader political landscape in Michigan.

American Tariff Rebate Act Introduced by Rep. Valerie Foushee
The War on Poverty: A Lesson on Intentions and Outcomes
Reporters Blocked from White House by Trump Administration
Universities Should Reject Political Influence on Research Funding
Trump’s Approach to China: Trade Dynamics and Challenges
Media Outlets Sue After White House Ban