President Donald Trump’s legal team is marking a significant moment as a judge has denied The New York Times’ motion to dismiss his $15 billion defamation lawsuit. U.S. District Judge Steven D. Merryday has allowed four counts related to seven accusations of criminal conduct to move forward, as Trump’s team accused the Times and publisher Penguin Random House of showing reckless disregard for the truth.
In a statement, Trump’s legal representatives emphasized their commitment to holding the media accountable. They accused The New York Times of having a consistent pattern of defaming Trump to further its political agenda. Judge Merryday’s decision is seen as a victory for transparency and honesty.
Judge Merryday criticized authors Susanne Craig and Russ Buettner for their book “Lucky Loser: How Donald Trump Squandered His Father’s Fortune and Created the Illusion of Success.” He noted that the authors presented accusations of tax fraud and money laundering without formal legal opinions or audits, which he found inadequate for making such claims.
The judge highlighted that accusations were made without charges or convictions, indicating potential awareness by the authors and publishers of the lack of substantial evidence.
Trump’s legal team argued that the Times and Penguin Publishing acted recklessly. The court dismissed the paper’s reliance on outside commentators who suggested that Trump’s transactions were suspicious or criminal in nature.
Judge Merryday also rejected some of Trump’s claims, dismissing two counts and 27 statements as non-actionable under the First Amendment protections established by New York Times Co. v. Sullivan. Trump’s request to amend his complaint further was denied.
The New York Times expressed encouragement at most claims being dismissed and reiterated their belief that the remaining claim lacks legal merit. They are preparing to defend against what they consider an attack on press freedom.
The judge has instructed The New York Times to submit a formal answer within 28 days.

Teen Killer of Tessa Majors Released Early
Prosecutors Decide Not to Charge LAPD Officer in Fatal 2024 Shooting
Murdaugh Defense Challenges Grand Jury Testimony
College Student Charged with Assaulting Fellow Student
Texas Execution Raises Concerns Over Protocols
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court to Review Clancy’s Murder Charge Dismissal Bid