An Alaska judge has deemed a request from Democratic U.S. Senate candidate Mary Peltola’s campaign for a list of absentee voters whose ballots were rejected as “not reasonable.” The decision comes amid ongoing ballot counts from last week’s election, where Peltola is contesting against the Republican incumbent, Sen. Dan Sullivan.
This election features a ranked voting system, and Alaska’s Senate race remains undecided. The state allows ballots from overseas voters to be accepted up to 15 days after the general election, with the final receipt date set for November 18. This date also marks when the Division of Elections plans to conduct ranked vote tabulations, should no candidate achieve over 50% of the initial first-choice votes.
Peltola’s campaign attorneys filed a lawsuit last Friday against state election officials, seeking the release of a list of rejected absentee voters and the reasons behind their rejection. The goal was to ensure all eligible voters’ ballots are counted, though attorneys for the state argued it would breach voter privacy. They also cited that generating such a list from the voter database could not take precedence under state law over the main responsibilities of the agency.
Superior Court Judge Thomas Matthews ruled in writing that while theoretically possible, producing redacted records from the voter database is not required. He stated the information could not be reasonably produced or redacted at this time. The division, facing deadlines, is focused on fulfilling its essential duty of conducting elections efficiently.
Judge Matthews remarked that the timing of the request “could simply not be worse.” An inquiry for comments from one of Peltola’s legal representatives was not returned on Wednesday, a public holiday. The state’s Department of Law expressed satisfaction with the ruling.
During courtroom arguments, Abha Khanna, a lawyer for Peltola’s campaign, stressed they did not intend to disrupt the ballot counting process, noting the absentee ballot review was progressing “incredibly smoothly.” Khanna contended the requested information is publicly accessible and in line with what campaign observers can view where absentee review boards convene.
State attorneys argued that reports generated by the division containing ballot lists to be reviewed are sensitive and not public records, describing them as “ephemeral working documents” meant for internal use. Michaela Thompson, who manages the absentee ballot review boards, noted that reports observed by campaign affiliates do not disclose as much sensitive information but include home addresses, which many voters prefer to keep private.
These observers must sign confidentiality agreements, agreeing not to retain, copy, or record data from the report. Thompson remarked that the current database could not generate reports without including confidential addresses, so the division would need to collaborate with a vendor to develop a customized report.

Amy Klobuchar Takes On Governorship with Promises for Minnesota’s Growth
Challenges of Signature Requirements for Political Candidates in Illinois
Debate Rekindled Over Gray Wolves and Livestock Losses
White House Faces Backlash Over Controversial Video
Former Press Secretary Critiques Republican Strategies
Migration, Politics, Peace Talks, Health Alerts, Legal Settlements, and Fire Conviction News