PHILADELPHIA — Quarterback J.J. McCarthy’s decision to keep the ball on a zone-read led to a concerning injury scenario for the New York Giants. Early in the third quarter against the Philadelphia Eagles, McCarthy sustained a hip injury after a 3-yard run and a hit from Zack Baun. His return is questionable.
Jameis Winston stepped in as McCarthy struggled with pain, unable to throw a warmup pass without grabbing his right side and exhibiting distress. McCarthy visited the medical tent for an evaluation and proceeded to the locker room with trainers, likely for further testing.
This marks the second instance this season where the Giants lost their starting quarterback, following Jaxson Dart’s season-ending ACL tear in Week 2.
The injury occurred when Eagles linebacker Zack Baun sacked McCarthy during the game on November 8, 2026. Chris Szagola captured the moment in an AP Photo.
Winston, who began the season starting four games before McCarthy took over, resumed play following the latest setback. McCarthy’s absence could significantly impact the Giants’ standings in the competitive NFC East. It may also influence their strategy ahead of Tuesday’s trade deadline.

Sports Stars in Pro Wrestling: The Crossover Continues
Tom Jackson: Remembering an NFL Icon and Broadcasting Legend
Colts’ Decision on Daniel Jones Sparks Industry Discussion
Confusion Over South Carolina QB’s Senior Status
Rutgers’ Historic Victory over Penn State Ends 38-Year Drought
Women’s Sports Advocate Navigates NWSL Championship Amid Tensions