2026 MLB Postseason Predictions

The Wild Card round of the 2026 MLB Playoffs is complete, leading to the Division Series. All four matchups begin on Saturday. The Rotoworld Baseball staff shared their insights on how the postseason might unfold. Below are their predictions and analysis for the Division Series, Championship Series, and World Series.

Division Series Matchups

White Sox vs. Guardians – Christopher Crawford believes there is little difference between the White Sox and Guardians. However, the White Sox’s impressive road wins in the postseason give them an edge. Despite lacking a scientific explanation, he favors the White Sox’s momentum.

Yankees vs. Rays – D.J. Short points out the Yankees and Rays meet in front of fans for the second time. The Rays had a stronger regular season, but the Yankees are seen as better postseason contenders. Their rotation led the majors with a 3.30 ERA, complemented by a bullpen at 3.15 ERA. Aaron Judge’s participation is uncertain due to injury. New York’s powerful lineup is expected to outperform the Rays’ small-ball approach.

Braves vs. Dodgers – Matthew Pouliot notes the Braves’ struggle to manage their rotation against the Phillies. Without Chris Sale and Tyler Mahle starting, they face challenges against the Dodgers. Starting Sale in Game 2 would require short rest, so he is slated for Game 3, with Mahle in Game 4. The Braves’ compromised pitching depth places them at a disadvantage.

Padres vs. Brewers – Eric Samulski acknowledges the Padres’ hot performance against the Cubs. Despite this, his research shows momentum doesn’t always predict postseason success. He believes in the Brewers, who have consistently been among the strongest teams, boasting a tough lineup and deep pitching staff.

Full MLB Postseason Predictions

• Eric Samulski: ALCS Winner – New York Yankees; NLCS Winner – Milwaukee Brewers; World Series Champion – Milwaukee Brewers
• Matthew Pouliot: ALCS Winner – New York Yankees; NLCS Winner – Los Angeles Dodgers; World Series Champion – Los Angeles Dodgers
• David Shovein: ALCS Winner – Tampa Bay Rays; NLCS Winner – Milwaukee Brewers; World Series Champion – Tampa Bay Rays
• Christopher Crawford: ALCS Winner – New York Yankees; NLCS Winner – San Diego Padres; World Series Champion – San Diego Padres
• D.J. Short: ALCS Winner – New York Yankees; NLCS Winner – San Diego Padres; World Series Champion – New York Yankees

Commentary on Predictions

Samulski: Admits a bias against the Yankees, favoring the Brewers for their potential breakthrough. Although the Yankees were strong against the Red Sox, their proneness to strikeouts suggests possible vulnerability against the consistent Brewers.

Pouliot: Recent improvements in the Dodgers’ bullpen have removed a major weakness. Diaz, Sasaki, and Phillips are performing effectively. Despite challenges, the Dodgers’ strong pitching could lead to success in low-scoring games.

Crawford: Despite not considering the Padres the top team, their current performance, strong bullpen, and rotation depth make them potential champions.

Short: Values the Yankees’ pitching staff and anticipates Aaron Judge’s return, enhancing their World Series outlook. Although the Padres present a tough offense and bullpen, the Yankees’ superior starting rotation is expected to be decisive.