On September 18, 2003, Justine Vanderschoot’s remains were discovered in a remote location. Her disappearance and the events that followed have had a lasting impact on her family and community, over 21 years later.
In the garden outside Justine’s bedroom window, her parents, Don and Lynnette, created a space they call “Justine’s Garden.” It serves as a place of remembrance for their youngest child. A towering dogwood tree stands at the center, symbolizing her favorite trips to the Sierra mountains and marking the passage of time since her tragic death.
Lynnette Vanderschoot commented, “It’s been 21 years since we lost Justine, yet her memory is still fresh in our minds.”
Justine’s sister Christine described her as “vibrant and charismatic, the life of the party.” She was engaged in numerous activities, from cheerleading to soccer, and had dreams of pursuing a career in fashion and beauty. Her innate ability to design clothes reflected her desire to make people stand out and feel beautiful.
A Family’s Struggle
Justine’s family has had to grapple with her murder and its legal aftermath. Don Vanderschoot expressed his struggle, stating, “I don’t ever want to forget her, but I don’t want to be reminded of what happened.” Unfortunately, the legal battles have kept the wounds open, with Justine’s convicted murderers, Danny Bezemer and Brandon Fernandez, pursuing parole.
Retired Placer County Sheriff Ed Bonner recounted, “The Vanderschoots have been back to court seven times in the last seven years, facing the possibility of release for those responsible for their daughter’s death.”
Dangerous Relationships
Both Danny and Brandon were once welcome in the Vanderschoot home. Brandon, a friend from Christine’s school days, introduced Danny to the family. Justine and Danny quickly became close at around age 15 and 17. As Danny lacked a stable family, he found comfort in the Vanderschoot household.
Reflecting on past events, Don and Christine Vanderschoot noticed Danny’s controlling behavior towards Justine. He monitored her communications, dictating whom she could see. Lindsey Morris, Brandon’s girlfriend, recounted that Justine confided in her about her dissatisfaction in the relationship.
“He was jealous and possessive,” said Lindsey. To her, Justine expressed doubts about whether she could end the relationship, fearing Danny might not let her go.
The Search for Justice
In the early hours of September 2, 2003, Justine’s empty bedroom and missing truck raised alarm. Her family and community organized massive search efforts, wearing T-shirts with her photo and distributing missing posters.
Eventually, her truck was located at a park and ride, pointing investigators closer to her location. Despite initial suspicion being directed toward a Navy man Justine had met in Florida, a recorded phone call from Brandon revealed inconsistencies in his alibi, eventually leading him to confess under investigation pressure.
Legal Struggles and Community Impact
Danny Bezemer and Brandon Fernandez were arrested and charged with Justine’s murder. In plea deals, Danny received a sentence of 25 years to life and Brandon 15 years to life. Justine’s family made it their mission to prevent any chance of parole, attending hearings and fighting changes in California law that might alter convictions.
Their efforts extended beyond personal justice. The Vanderschoots advocated for victims’ rights and teen dating violence prevention, contributing to the passage of Justine’s Law in 2023. This law provides educational programs on dating violence in California high schools.
The Vanderschoots still find solace in Justine’s Garden, where Lynnette feels embraced by memories of her daughter. The family’s ongoing fight in the legal system underscores their commitment to preserving Justine’s legacy and preventing similar tragedies.