Introduction

Recent polling by AP-NORC reveals a growing divide in the symbols of pride that Americans identify with as the country approaches its 250th anniversary. This division is particularly noticeable between Democrats, Republicans, and independents in how they celebrate national pride.

Democrats Favor Pop Culture Over Military

Democrats are showing a pronounced shift in pride, with many favoring America’s pop culture over traditional symbols like the military. While Republicans continue to express overwhelming admiration for the armed forces, Democrats’ pride in the military has significantly decreased. In contrast, pride in cultural aspects such as music, film, and television has remained stable among Democrats, making pop culture a central element of their national pride.

Statistical Changes in Military Pride

Data shows a marked decline in pride in the military among Democrats from 74% in 2017 to 42% today. This overall reduction in national pride extends beyond the military to American democracy, history, and political influence, pointing to broader institutional mistrust.

A Broader Decline in Institutional Pride Among Americans

Pride in national institutions has decreased nationwide, notably among Democrats. The AP-NORC poll highlights diminished pride in American military, democracy, and historical achievements. Partisan divisions are stark, with Republicans maintaining strong pride in these institutions.

Republican Values Anchored in Military Pride

Republicans consistently uphold the military as a national pride point, aligning with their greater propensity to view America as prosperous and powerful. Many Republicans express their pride through displays such as flying the American flag and emphasizing the importance of their national identity.

Implications for the 250th Anniversary Celebrations

The differing perceptions of national pride will impact the upcoming semiquincentennial celebrations. The poll indicates mixed emotions about the anniversary among Americans, with only 40% feeling proud and notable differences between Democrat and Republican sentiments.

Official celebrations, which prominently feature military ceremonies, may resonate less with Democrats. Instead, Democrats might find greater connection with events celebrating cultural diversity and creativity.

Redefining Patriotism and National Identity

These cultural differences point to a shifting landscape in American patriotism. As traditional symbols lose traction with Democrats, cultural expressions become more significant. This transition will have long-term effects on political debates and the narrative of American identity.

As the United States enters a new chapter, these divisions in national pride are likely to influence how Americans celebrate their country and the symbols they choose to honor.

For additional information, contact Newsweek editors Jenni Fink and Sam Wilson.